handyDART info

All that's happening with custom transit in Metro Vancouver

 

buspic
 

handyDART in Greater Vancouver is currently in a state of crisis. How did this happen and why is it a crisis? For answers to these questions, read the short history and the links to more a detailed accounts of events and documents.

History

TransLink has contracted handyDART operations in Greater Vancouver and some neighbouring areas. The system was operated under eight contracts roughly corresponding to the various municipalities. Most of the contractors were unionized with one of three unions (CAW, ATU and BCGEU).

After a debacle with the City of Vancouver contract held by Pacific Transit Cooperative [click here], TransLink decided to amalgamate the system into three areas with one contract for each, and to centralize registration and reservation functions in a subsidiary instead of including them in the individual contracts [click here].

A Request for Proposals (RFP) was issued for each the three areas: North of Fraser [click here], South of Fraser [click here] and Maple Ridge/Pitt Meadows [click here]. Each RFP had one unique feature; the invitation to propose an alternate service model.

There were a number of proposals made for each contract [click here], but only two companies applied for all three areas, neither a current contractor. One of them was selected for all three areas: MVT Canadian, a subsidiary of MVT Transporatation (MVT), a large American company [click here]. TransLink's announcement indicated that a significant reason for this decision was MVT's intention to consolidate all three contract areas into one integrated operation [click here].

TransLink did not disclose its preference for such consolidation to the proponents in the RFP process.

Now

The selection of MVT has pleased user advocates such as the BC Coalition of People with Disabilities because it promises to provide a single seamless transportation system without boundary transfers.

However, the selection of MVT raises a number of questions:

  • Was MVT a good choice for the system and its users?
  • Was selection on an undisclosed criterion fair and proper to all the proponents?
  • Was this choice of proponents fair to the unions concerned?

Unfortunately, the answers to all three questions is no.

MVT

Given the number of experienced handyDART contractors, most of whom have been very successful in providing excellent service within the terms of their contracts, it is surprising that TransLink would select an American company with no prior experience in BC. TransLink stated that MVT "has established a reputation for strong customer service, innovative operations and on-time performance." However, there are troubling reports that contradict that impression. Here are some of what has been reported:

  • A 78 year old man died of injuries after falling down a flight of stairs at a house (the wrong address) where he had been mistakenly dropped off by a MV paratransit bus. [click here]
     
  • East African immigrants filed a lawsuit against MV Transportation, a minority-owned transportation company, alleging discrimination based on nationality and religion. [click here]

 

other organizations online

TransLink
responsible for provision of custom transit services and contracts their operation to others

BC Coalition of People with Disabilities
respected advocacy group

Pacific Transit Cooperative
currently operates the handyDART system in the City of Vancouver

3120 Ventures Ltd.
currently operates the handyDART system in North Vancouver and West Vancouver cities

Deltassist Family & Community Services
operates the handyDART system in Delta

Options: Services to Communities Society
operates the handyDART system in Surrey

Greater Vancouver Community Services Society
currently operates the handyDART system in Richmond and Simon Fraser areas

Semiahmoo House Society
currently operates the handyDART system in Whiterock, South Surrey and Langley

D. W. Services Ltd.
currently operates the handyDART system in the Maple Ridge - Pitt Meadows area

MV Transportation Inc.
American parent of MVT Canadian Bus which was selected by TransLink to replace the current contractors and operate handyDART services in all three Greater Vancouver service areas from January 2009

Canadian Auto Workers Union Local 114
represents handyDART employees in some areas

BC Government & Service Employees' Union
represents handyDART employees in some areas

Amalgamated Transit Union Local 1724
represents handyDART employees of Pacific Transit Cooperative

handydart.org
an ATU sponsored pro-ATU blog and forum for Pacific Transit Cooperative drivers